Construction procurement methods or delivery types have evolved over the years with economic times, trends, and clear understanding of each style. Often the delivery type is chosen based on previous experience, our goal is to broaden the understanding of each type from a very high level. Generally, there are four delivery methods chosen in the commercial construction industry: Design-Bid-Build, Construction Manager at Risk, Construction Manager Advisor, and Design Build. We have included a brief description of each, with several pros and cons highlighted, focusing on the timing of the general contractor’s involvement in the process.
Design-Bid-Build (Hard Bid): The project is fully designed, and plans are given to unknown general contractor (GC) to review all scope and bid out projects. Low bid wins with little to no input from GC early on.
Pros:
Construction Manager at Risk (CMaR): Strong relationship with GC as they are early in design phase via a negotiated or RFP process. GC assists with cost estimating, scheduling, and a guaranteed maximum price (GMP) is set before design complete/construction start.
Pros:
Cons:
Construction Manager Advisor (CMa): A hybrid of the above two delivery methods, the GC is brought on during design via a relationship driven process or RFP with the ability to impact scope and schedule. Once hired bid packages are set, and low subcontractor bid wins on bid day, owner holds the contracts with GC overseeing all trades as a single point of contact.
Pros:
Cons:
Design Build: The design team and general contractor are hired simultaneously early on or the team partnered prior to selection due to a long-standing relationship and shared experience.
Pros:
Cons:
The goal of all four methods is to bring every project in on time and under budget, each procurement process achieves this goal uniquely. Our goal at AP is to educate clients and provide them the information necessary to select the delivery method that aligns with their needs while building trust and ongoing relationships for future work.